“I’m her…sorta..like.. Maisie’s stepfather” – Lincoln
Number of Times Seen – 1 (13 Feb 2014)
Brief Synopsis – A nasty divorce told from the perspective of a 6 year old girl.
My Take on it – This movie was recommended to me by Mikey @ Screenkicker.
I hadn’t heard about this one before, but was quite impressed with the way it was done.
I personally have been thru a messy divorce and know of numerous others who have also. One thing that happens in divorce situations very often is that both sides try to do what’s best for them first and foremost and only after that do they think of any child welfare.
Too often, when people deal with their own problems they forget to think about others that are affected by the situation
Sad, but very true.
This movie tells the story of a divorce completely from the child’s perspective and it is very effective. The child actress who plays Maisie (Onata Aprile) appears in every scene in this movie and many times, we only hear parts of “adult” conversations which gives us an even clearer child perspective (since rarely do 6 years old understand everything going on around them).
I don’t think I’ve ever seen a movie that tells a story straight from a child’s perspective. (Even the camera shots are quite often from a child’s view).
The thing with this movie is that its unique perspective is both its saving grace and also its minor flaw. The fact that we only hear parts of conversations requires the viewer to put together parts of the plot on their own which are left purposely ambiguous.
Not everything in movies need to be spoon fed, but it all depends on the type of movie.
After watching this, Mikey informed me that this movie was based on a book by Henry James from the late 19th Century which just blew my mind.
It’s hard to believe that something like this was written over a hundred years ago (as a concept obviously) and still ring true now.
I guess it just goes to show that people and their situations don’t change much even after a century. People who are selfish will remain selfish.
Bottom Line – Amazing idea. Skillfully done but something is slightly missing from it. Recommended!
Rating – Globe Worthy
Check out my *updated* movie stats here
To see my reviews of all Oscar Best Picture Winners click here
Good review. Agreed that something is missing. I think Maisie’s caretakers needed to be a bit better developed.
They weren’t developed on purpose b/c we only see what Maisie sees and it would be very hard for a kid to show us developed adults since she doesn’t understand at all what is really going on around her.
Thanks for commenting JJ
I think that is true to a point. We have a pretty good understanding of Maisie’s parents, even given the child point of view, because the director’s are wise enough to let us hear (and occasionally see) things Maisie doesn’t understand.
They don’t do the same with Margot and Lincoln, which means so many of their decisions seem senseless. I think the randomness of these two characters’ behavior takes us out of the film, at least a little, and thereby reduces the emotion we feel.
Which isn’t to say this is bad. I still gave it a B. I still like it.
True, but the point was to show their connections with Maisie and how she relates to them as surrogates.
I think we pretty much agree here 🙂
I think so, too. It’s a minor difference, to be sure, but while I know what the filmmakers were going for Lincoln and Margot’s connection to Maisie, I think they needed to give the viewer a touch more (like they did with her parents).
maybe so, but, alas, we shall never know 🙂
Glad you enjoyed it mate. I saw it at a film festival last year and really liked it. Great review!
Thanks for stopping by and commenting Mikey. Of course, thanks also for the recommendation. I probably wouldn’t have ever come across this one on my own, so appreciate it.
Pingback: Movies Reviewed Index A-Z | MovieRob
Pingback: Temporal Top Ten – 2012 |