My Overall Thoughts:
This was a great year for movie fans because it heralded in the change in the popular thinking of the Academy. The first two parts of the LOTR trilogy also garnered BP noms in the two previous years, but despite the films being amazing both on a technical and narrative level, neither had much of a chance because they were left without clear endings.
The win this year was proof that even a film in the fantasy genre could be a powerhouse and take home just about every award because it was done amazingly.
Both Seabisuit and Mystic River were also amazing films, but neither had the momentum of 3 years behind them to propel them to the top slot.
MR is one of Eastwood’s best films and the characters are superbly written and in a different year (perhaps 2002 or 2004, it might have been ale to take home the award for BP.
- 5. – Master and Commander – A pretty boring tale of the high seas with Crowe doing his best at making this succeed despite the challenges of the story
- 4. – Lost in Translation – Murray once again shows how versatile an actor he can be in this low key drama that sometimes feels like a comedy
- 3. – Mystic River – Eastwood gives us a gripping tale with an amazing cast. One of his best films, but couldn’t overcome the juggernaut of the year that had too much momentum three years running
- 2. – Seabiscuit – Very emotional and amazing story really helps us believe in the magic of human-animal companionship and the need to do your best no matter what.
- 1. – The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King – The finale of this series shows why it was so amazing from both a storytelling and technical viewpoint. A bit long for most people but for others it was long enough in Middle Earth. Great way to break the taboo of fantasy not being able to take home the top prize.
Do I agree with the Oscar winner? – YES!! There is no doubt in most people’s minds at how amazing a cinematic achievement this film series was. The other two parts were also equally powerful and had they had proper endings, they might have been able to also win. The win here tho is for the series overall and for the fantasy genre in particular because the Academy members proved that if the film is done so well like this one was, it doesn’t matter the genre, it is possible to sweep and also take home the top award.
Let me know what you think about these films and my rankings!