Movies From the Hat V #11 – Catherine’s Pick – The Proposition (2005)

This is my 2960th Review

Thanks to Catherine of Thoughts All Sorts for this recommendation.

Here are her thoughts on the film.

Number of Times Seen – 1 (19 Mar 2017)

Brief Synopsis – An outlaw captured  in Australia is given a deal by the law;  he must kill his notorious older brother otherwise, they will hang his younger brother.

My Take on it – This is a film that I had never even heard of before it was recommended to me and just by seeing the premise, I had high hopes that it would be quite good.

Unfortunately, it’s paced way too slowly and although that is sometimes good with a Western, it wasn’t in this case.

Things feel too drawn out and I believe that had the pace been quickened a bit, it would have been even more enjoyable.

The cast is quite competent here, but I constantly had the feeling that Guy Pierce was terribly cast in the lead role in this film.

He was great in L.A. Confidential (1997) and in Memento (2000) as a sort of anti-hero who we can sympathize with, but here, he plays an extremely ruthless character and IMHO. it just doesn’t fit him well.

I also found it quite strange that this is perceived as a Western , yet takes place in the Outback of Australia.  I’m sure that there were Cowboys there, but it just seemed a bit strange to me.

This is quite a violent film, so it isn’t for those without a strong stomach.

All in all, some parts work better than others, but I thought this was a pretty average kinda Western.

Bottom Line – Interesting premise that just doesn’t work as well as I would have hoped. Cast is quite competent, but Pierce isn’t as good playing a ruthless character as he is as an anti-hero. The pace is too slow and I think had it moved a bit quicker, it would have been even more enjoyable.  Personally, found it strange having a Western that takes place in the Australian Outback.

MovieRob’s Favorite Trivia – One of the gunmen in the Burns’ fort at the beginning is named “Jack Bradshaw”. Although the movie’s plot was fictitious, there had been a real 19th century Australian “bushranger” (outlaw) by that name. (From IMDB)

Rating – BAFTA Worthy


Check out my *updated* movie stats here

To see my reviews of Oscar Winning Performances check out this link

To see my reviews of all Oscar Best Picture Winners click here (now complete)

Here is a link to my movie index A-Z

15 thoughts on “Movies From the Hat V #11 – Catherine’s Pick – The Proposition (2005)

  1. Thanks for watching this Rob! Appreciated. You know, having watched it again last night…as much as I enjoy all the sets, music etc, I do actually think the pace is a tad too slow. While I was watching I was thinking…gosh, did I recommend this to Rob…he may think it booring! 😉

    Liked by 1 person

    • right on the money! 🙂

      it’s not the worst Ive seen for this series, just struggled thru 2 really bad films this morning… one was horrendous!!!! Cant believe it was recommended to me. I think I’m gonna unfriend the recommender 🙂

      This series is all about trial and error. I don’t expect to love or even like all of the suggestions, I just want to try and watch what others perceive as great films that I haven’t yet been exposed to.

      Liked by 2 people

      • And, I really enjoy how “recommender” and “recomendee” don’t always have the same opinion. That’s what makes it so interesting. I also enjoy being “challenged” i.e. hearing your opinion makes me think a bit.
        Now you’ve got me all curious about the horrendous film. In a weird way, looking forward to your review…
        But, if it makes you feel any better – I watched a horrid one on the weekend – I should have known, IMDB gave it a 3 or so rating but people commented that it wasn’t really that bad….well, trust me, it was worse than bad…so, avoid “Without Men”


  2. Pingback: Proposing The Proposition | Thoughts All Sorts

  3. Pingback: Temporal Top Ten – 2005 |

Let me Know what you think!!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.