The idea behind this feature (Genre Guesstimation) is for me to watch a bunch of new movies (or ones that I haven’t seen many times) from the chosen monthly GG genre in order to expand my knowledge of movies within that particular genre.
This month’s Genre has been chosen by Samantha Ellis of Musing of a Classic Film Addict and it is Romantic Films
“This could include any movie with a romantic pairing as the central focus of the plot, be it a comedy, drama, horror, or what have you.”
Please get me your submissions by the 25th of Jan by sending them to firstname.lastname@example.org
Try to think out of the box! Great choice Samantha!
Let’s see if I felt that this movie would be worthy of being in the company of my others favorite movies in the genre of Romantic Films.…
“$2.95″ – Alfred Kralik
“Oh, no!” – Woman Customer [walks away]
Number of Times Seen – 1 (17 Jan 2019)
Brief Synopsis – Two co-workers at a gift store in Europe can’t stand each other, and don’t realize that they are secretly corresponding with one another through the mail.
My Take on it – I decided that in order to make my guest choices of the Genre for the Genre Grandeur series more personal (and expand my own personal horizons of these genres), I will take a recommendation from my guest for a film to watch for this Genre Guesstimation series.
This movie was Samantha’s choice for me to watch.
The concept of this film is one that I was quite familiar with since I’m a big fan of the 1999 remake with Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan – You’ve Got Mail (1999).
The way things are presented here was probably much better when seen through the eyes of someone in 1940 than it can be now because it doesn’t flow as smoothly as a story like this one should.
THe cast is quite good and Jimmy Stewart and Margaret Sullavan have very nice chemistry together.
This is more difficult than one might think since there characters are meant to hate one another when meeting in person, yet when writing to one another they are completely different people.
The story itself begins quite well, but over the course of the movie, they lose much of the credibility established at the beginning because of the way that they choose to present certain aspects of the storyline which doesn’t work as well as one might hope.
This is one of the rare cases when a movie’s remake is much better than the original because they manage to keep thing much more interesting even though the concept is virtually identical.
Bottom Line – Great concept for a romance film that probably worked much better when it came out than it does now. The cats is quite good and Stewart and Sullavan have nice chemistry together despite the fact that they are meant to hate one another when they are shown together. The story itself starts off really well, but loses a lot of its credibiloty along the way due to the choices of how to present certain aspects of the storyline. This is a rare exampe of a film that was remade and the remake is actually much more enjoyable. REcommended!
MovieRob’s Favorite Trivia – Even though Margaret Sullavan was infamous for her quick temper and disdainful attitude towards Hollywood, James Stewart counted working with her as one of the great joys of his professional career. And because he knew her personally, he was more equipped than most of the cast and crew members to deal with her frequent and volatile emotional outbursts. (From IMDB)
Genre Grandeur Worthy? – Come close, but the story loses most of its credibility along the way due to the choices on how to present things. The remake with Hanks and Ryan is so much more enjoyable.
Rating – Globe Worthy (7/10)