Did They Get it Right? – Best Picture – Oscars 2010

dtgirbp-2010Here are the ten nominees: (Winner in Bold)

127 Hours
Black Swan
The Fighter
The Kids Are All Right
The King’s Speech
The Social Network
Toy Story 3
True Grit
Winter’s Bone

Biggest Snub:


My Overall Thoughts:

Once again, with a list of 10 films on this list, it feels as if the Academy stretches the “bar” a bit and includes films that are good but not great in the final list.

It seems as if they felt that they were required to name ten films on this list despite many of them not really deserving to be on the list.

Looking at the list, I am still shocked that they expanded the list of nominees to 10 because it gives a greater status to films that shouldn’t really be in this class of eliteness.

What’s interesting is that most of these undeserving films for the BP nomination are all lead by amazing performances. Perhaps, those performances are what’s  give the impression that the films are better than they truly are.

My Rankings:


  • 10.-Black Swan – Great performance by Portman, but a complete mess of a film that makes little to no sense.
  • 9. – The Kid’s Are All Right – More or less mediocre film that has its moments, but overall doesn’t really deliver like it could have.
  • 8. – 127 Hours – Franco does a great job here, but the film itself isn’t as emotionally poignant as one would hope and expect.
  • 7. – Winter’s Bone – Lawrence shows here how great an actress she is, but the story is a bit lacking and doesn’t give the epic feel that is sorely needed.
  • 6. – True Grit – Good film but doesn’t add much to the original film’s premise. Steinfeld is great here and it’s fun watching Bridges, Damon and Brolin. The Coen Brothers always have interesting ways of telling stories and this is no exception, but the truth is that there isn’t much added to this story that would really warrant it being remade besides their more realistic views of violence and the story itself.
  • 5. – The Fighter – The performances of the four main actors are brilliant here, but the story itself is a bit lacking which doesn’t bring it up to the level where it really should deserve a nomination.
  • 4. – The Social Network – Sorkin once again shows how amazing a writer he is with this film. This movie was a front-runner for a time but due to controversy over its accuracy, it lost a lot of steam along the way.
  • 3. – The King’s Speech – Amazing historical epic that has some amazing performances.  Not the very best film of the year, but close enough to still be deserving of its win.
  • 2. – Toy Story 3 – PIXAR proved with this film that even the third film in a trilogy can be amazing.  The message here about growing up is quiet poignant and the use of animation to give over this message is the perfect medium.
  • 1. – Inception – Nolan is one of the best directors around and he is able to create a world here that is so vivid and full of surprises. The story works on so many different levels and the fact that you never know what is real or not makes things even more amazing to watch unfold around us. This is clearly the best film of the year from both a technical and narrative perspective.

Do I agree with the Oscar winner? – Yes and No!  The King’s Speech is a superb historic film but the two other films that I rank higher probably wouldn’t have had a chance at winning BP because of the genre’s they belong to.  I am looking forward to the day when an animated film or a psychological action film will be able to take home that top gold statue.

Let me know what you think about these films and my rankings!

13 thoughts on “Did They Get it Right? – Best Picture – Oscars 2010

  1. Inception…what a brilliant and clever movie! Of your list, yes, I’d also put it where you have although I haven’t seen Winters’s Bone (been meaning to) or The Fighter (maybe one day). I’m not sure 127 Hours was worthy – at times it felt like I was sitting through it for as many hours.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I actually think Social Network is way overrated. It to me didnt make Zuckerberg a real person that I related to but just another corrupt rich guy. I love Kings Speech, Toy Story 3 and Inception

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Yes, yes, yes! Inception should have won, but The King’s Speech was a good if more conventional choice. They probably could have kept the nominees to those two, Toy Story 3, Social Network, and True Grit, and been perfectly fine.


  4. Another great Oscar ranking, Rob! I love these articles 🙂 Ranking the nominees really helps show the differences in opinions with us movie nerds, which is what makes talking movies so awesome. Of course, I have to chime in with my rankings. You know me, I dig on some of the artsie stuff, but also love me some popcorn flicks.

    For the rankings, I still haven’t seen King’s Speech or Toy Story 3. I dismissed them as melodrama and kids flick, but should probably give them a chance, especially with your thoughts on K.Speech.

    My two cents…

    8. True Grit – I liked all of these movies, but the Coens remake was a little dry at times, and a little slow. However, it had great cinematography and some impressive acting. I think it ranks up there with the original though. Bridges was great, but Steinfeld was the revelation here.

    7. Kids Are All Right – I really liked this character piece, focused on real issues we can all relate to. Impressive acting and writing. This made me pay attention to Mark Ruffalo a bit more.

    6. Winter’s Bone – This was my first encounter with Jennifer Lawrence. She was a revelation as well. Another strong character piece. I enjoyed the deliberate pace and the constantly tightening tension. John Hawkes was fantastic too.

    5. 127 Hours – Although I knew the story and how it would end, this was still entirely captivating. Surprisingly energetic. Tremendous filmmaking with an intriguing narrative. Strong performance from Franco too.

    4. The Fighter – Another excellent character piece. Incredible performances all around, even with non-actor extras.

    3. Social Network – Amazing character piece. Phenomenal dialogue and direction. Atmospheric score slow brews tension. Exciting biopic despite dense material.

    2. Inception – Astounding blend of art and popcorn. Provocative in all the best ways. Stunning action set-pieces. Just complicated enough. Interpretive and engaging. An amazing blend of adventure and head-scratching.

    1, Black Swan – Brilliant filmmaking. Interpretive exploration of the fractured mind (those reflections everywhere and how they distort reality). They way Aronofsky imagines mental illness is pulse-pounding. Thematic but not overwhelming, I thought this was the best Hitchcock film Hitchcock never made. Unsettling and introspective, yet Portman’s magnetic performance drew me in.


  5. BS is a bit WTF 😉 For sure. I don’t think intellect has anything to do with it. Sometimes, I think it depends on how excited the viewer is to participate. If they aren’t excited by the material why think about it while they watch. It’s like enjoying different kinds of music, not everyone digs on the same sounds… regardless of intellect.

    Liked by 1 person

Let me Know what you think!!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.